The Only Time In History An American Battleship Fought A French Battleship

15 min read

Four minutes past seven in the morning, November eighth, nineteen forty-two. Twelve miles off Casablanca, French Morocco. A battleship that is six months old, with a crew that has never heard her main guns fired at a living target, has just been straddled by shells from the shore. Her name is USS Massachusetts. Her nine sixteen-inch guns swing toward the harbor, toward a stone quay where the newest battleship in the French Navy is tied up. The order comes down from the flag bridge in two words. Play ball.

Nine guns fire together. The recoil shatters the windows on the bridge. The first sixteen-inch shells the United States ever fired in anger in the Second World War are in the air, and they are not aimed at Germany or Japan. They are aimed at France.

This is the only time in history an American battleship fought a French battleship. It is the only time an American battleship fought any battleship in the Atlantic. The figures here come from the ship's own gunnery record, from the French account of what each shell did inside Jean Bart, and from the United States Navy's official ship history.

By the end of this, you will know why two allies ended up shooting at each other, what five sixteen-inch shells did to a ship that was only half built, how a battleship that was supposed to be dead came back to life the same evening, and why the one American battleship that got into a gun duel with another battleship in that ocean fired almost every shell she carried.

To understand why an American battleship fired on a French one, start with June nineteen forty.

France was falling. German troops were moving down the Atlantic coast toward the shipyard at Saint-Nazaire, where the French Navy's newest battleship, Jean Bart, sat in her fitting-out dock. She was not finished. She had one of her two main turrets installed. The other, the one that was supposed to sit behind and above it, had no guns and no armor. She had a handful of anti-aircraft weapons and not much else.

On June nineteenth, nineteen forty, her crew took her out anyway, in the dark, hours ahead of the Germans. She grounded briefly on the way out and bent a propeller blade. She made it to sea. Three days later, on June twenty-second, she reached Casablanca, in French Morocco, on the Atlantic coast of North Africa. That same day, France signed an armistice with Germany.

That armistice is the key to everything that follows. The French government that signed it, based at Vichy, kept control of the French fleet and the French colonies. In return, it was obliged to defend them. Against anyone. Including the people who had been France's allies two weeks earlier.

Britain tested that within days. In July nineteen forty, at Mers-el-Kébir in Algeria, the Royal Navy opened fire on the French fleet rather than let it fall into German hands. More than a thousand French sailors died. French officers did not forget it.

The United States took the other path. Washington recognized Vichy and kept an ambassador there. For two years, American diplomats and French admirals talked. So when the Allies planned their first great landing of the war, the invasion of French North Africa in November nineteen forty-two, Operation Torch, the planners made it an American show on purpose. The intelligence said the French might fire on British troops. They might not fire on Americans.

They were wrong.

Casablanca was defended by Vice Admiral Frix Michelier. Until less than a month before the landings, he had served on the commission that enforced the armistice with Germany. He had a light cruiser, two large destroyers, seven smaller ones, eight sloops, eleven minesweepers and eleven submarines. He had a coastal battery on a headland called El Hank, built around a lighthouse: four guns of seven point six inches and four of five point four. And he had Jean Bart.

By November nineteen forty-two, Jean Bart had been at Casablanca for more than two years. The French had got her one turret working by May. Four guns, fifteen inches each, in a single mount. The empty barbette behind it had been filled with concrete. Her fire control was improvised: a rangefinder borrowed from elsewhere, with spotters ashore to help her triangulate. She could not move under her own power in any useful way. But she could shoot. Tied to the quay, she was a fixed battery of four fifteen-inch guns, with the heaviest armor in the harbor, and a crew that had been waiting a long time to use her.

USS Massachusetts was a treaty battleship, built to a limit of thirty-five thousand tons that the United States had agreed to in the nineteen twenties and then tried to stretch. She came in at just under thirty-eight thousand tons standard, six hundred and eighty feet long, with a top speed of twenty-seven and a half knots. The designers had packed nine sixteen-inch guns into a hull short enough to meet the limit, which gave her a cramped, blocky look next to the older battleships. Her crew called her Big Mamie.

She was commissioned at Boston on May twelfth, nineteen forty-two, under Captain Francis Whiting. She did her shakedown in the summer. In October she was in Casco Bay, Maine, when the orders came. She sailed on October twenty-fourth and met the rest of her group at sea four days later: the heavy cruisers Wichita and Tuscaloosa and four destroyers, under Rear Admiral Robert Giffen, who flew his flag in Massachusetts. This was the covering group for the whole Casablanca landing. Its job was to sit off the harbor and make sure nothing came out of it.

One detail matters for what happened next. Massachusetts had not yet received any high-capacity shells, the kind meant for shore targets. Every one of the eight hundred sixteen-inch rounds in her magazines was armor-piercing: two thousand seven hundred pounds each, built to go through a battleship's armor before exploding. Those were the shells she was going to have to use on everything, from Jean Bart to coastal guns to merchant ships.

The landings went in before dawn on November eighth, at Fedala, about fifteen miles up the coast from Casablanca. Three thousand five hundred American troops were ashore by first light. The covering group was already at sea off the harbor, working up toward twenty-five knots, passing the lighthouse at El Hank.

Just after seven, the French batteries opened fire on the landing craft at Fedala. And then, off Casablanca, Jean Bart fired.

Her first rounds splashed about six thousand yards off Massachusetts's starboard bow. Six thousand yards is three and a half miles short. It did not matter. Giffen had been waiting for the French to fire first, and now they had. The signal went out: Play ball.

At four minutes past seven, Massachusetts opened fire at a range of more than twelve miles. The sound of nine sixteen-inch guns going off together blew out the bridge windows. The shells took the better part of a minute to arrive. And the French, from their spotting positions ashore, started to find her. The battery at El Hank straddled her with its first salvo. Jean Bart's gunners, with their improvised rangefinder and only two of their four guns firing at a time, kept shooting.

What happened in the next hour is known in unusual detail, because the French recorded what every American shell did when it arrived.

At twenty-five past seven, the first hit. A sixteen-inch shell came down through Jean Bart's upper deck, through her armored deck, through the second armored deck beneath it, and exploded in a magazine. The magazine was empty. It had been built for secondary guns that had never been fitted. Had those guns been installed and the magazine filled, that one shell might have ended the ship.

Between thirty-five and thirty-seven minutes past seven, more arrived. A near miss off the bow bent her plating. A shell struck the stone quay beside her and threw fragments across her anti-aircraft gunners. Another went through her funnel and struck the edge of the armored deck. One more hit the quay, carved a gouge in it, passed clean through the bottom of the ship, and did not explode.

By most accounts, some of the American shells that morning failed to go off, and the fuzes in them were old stock, made for the last war. Massachusetts was firing the most powerful naval gun the United States had, with shells carrying fuzes that had sat in storage for twenty years.

At six minutes past eight, the hit that decided the duel. A sixteen-inch shell struck the front of Jean Bart's one working turret and drove the armored face plate downward, jamming the turret in train. It could no longer rotate. Its guns pointed where they were pointing and nowhere else. At the same moment, a second shell struck the empty, concrete-filled barbette behind the turret, and the fragments tore into the armored deck.

Four minutes later, at ten past eight, a shell came down on the quarterdeck and exploded in a ballast compartment, flooding the space that held the manual steering gear.

Five hits. In the American gunnery record, it took nine main-battery salvos and sixteen minutes to land them. Jean Bart had fired a handful of two-gun salvos back, and hit nothing. Her single turret was jammed. Her fire control was wrecked. By the Navy's count, she had been silenced.

Then the harbor emptied.

At nine in the morning, Rear Admiral Gervais de Lafond took seven ships of the Second Light Squadron out of Casablanca under a smoke screen. The two large destroyers Milan and Albatros, the smaller destroyers Fougueux, Boulonnais, Brestois, Frondeur and L'Alcyon. Behind them came the light cruiser Primauguet. Their target was not the American battleship. It was the troop transports anchored off Fedala, fifteen miles up the coast, full of soldiers and equipment that had not yet been landed. If the French destroyers got in among them, the landing could be wrecked in an hour.

Fighters from the carrier Ranger strafed the column as it came out. Then the American heavy ships turned on it.

At ten o'clock, Massachusetts and Tuscaloosa took Fougueux under fire. For a destroyer, a sixteen-inch armor-piercing shell is not a weapon so much as a demolition charge. At twenty minutes to eleven, Fougueux sank. Milan, hit by the destroyer Wilkes and the cruisers Wichita and Tuscaloosa, turned for the beach and ran herself aground to avoid sinking.

At ten o'clock, the same moment Fougueux was being hit, El Hank finally found Massachusetts. A seven point six inch shell struck her. The damage was minor, and the ship did not slow. It was the only hit she took in the battle.

At twelve minutes past ten, Massachusetts and Tuscaloosa shifted to Boulonnais. The heavy cruiser Augusta, flagship of the whole invasion, finished her at noon. Wichita took a shell from a coastal battery and had fourteen men wounded.

Then came the cruiser. Between eleven and twenty past, Augusta and the light cruiser Brooklyn, with her fifteen six-inch guns, caught Primauguet and her escorts. Albatros was hit so badly that she too beached herself. Brestois and Frondeur, shot through by Brooklyn, capsized. Primauguet, hit repeatedly, was run aground and burned out. Forty-five of her crew were killed and more than two hundred wounded.

By early afternoon, of the seven ships that had sortied, one, L'Alcyon, was still operational. The transports off Fedala had never been touched.

The submarines tried too. Five French boats had got out of the harbor at seven that morning, before the bombs from Ranger's aircraft destroyed three others at their moorings. Amazone fired torpedoes at Brooklyn and missed. One, Sibylle, simply vanished; nobody knows what happened to her. Two days later, Méduse and Antiope would fire at Massachusetts and Tuscaloosa, and miss again.

Through the rest of the day, Massachusetts kept shooting: at El Hank, at the submarine pens, at an ammunition dump, which she blew up, and at merchant ships in the commercial harbor. A sixteen-inch shell hit a floating dry dock with a French submarine inside it. The dock sank. The submarine, undamaged, got underway on her own.

Her gunnery record gives the numbers. Between four minutes past seven and four minutes past eleven, four hours, she fired fifty-nine percent of her entire outfit of sixteen-inch ammunition. By the end of the day she had fired a hundred and thirty-four salvos, seven hundred and eighty-six rounds out of the eight hundred she carried. Ninety-eight percent. Her gunners had been in commission for less than six months.

Now the part the Americans did not know.

Jean Bart was not dead. Her turret was jammed, not destroyed. While the battle went on outside the breakwater, French dockyard workers climbed onto the turret with cutting gear and went to work on the bent armor plate that was holding it. They cut the deformed steel away. At twenty-four minutes past five that evening, with the American ships still off the harbor, the turret turned again.

The Americans had written her off. They would find out two days later.

On November tenth, a pair of French sloops came out of Casablanca to fire on the American troops ashore. Augusta and two destroyers, Edison and Tillman, went in to drive them back. As they closed the harbor, Jean Bart opened fire. Between eleven forty-one and eleven fifty-one she fired nine two-gun salvos at the flagship of the invasion fleet. Three of them straddled her. Augusta turned away at high speed.

A battleship with sixteen-inch guns had hit Jean Bart five times and put her out of action for about nine hours. That afternoon, it was aircraft that finished the job: nine dive bombers from Ranger, two thousand-pound bomb hits, and Jean Bart settled by the stern into the harbor mud with her generators drowned. That story has its own episode on this channel. For Massachusetts, the point is simpler. The duel she had won on the morning of the eighth was not quite over when she thought it was.

On November eleventh, Casablanca surrendered. The armistice was signed. The French Navy in North Africa stopped fighting, and within weeks much of it would be fighting on the Allied side.

The French lost four hundred and sixty-two dead. Jean Bart alone had twenty-two killed and twenty-two wounded, from a crew that had been waiting two years for a fight that lasted one morning. On the American side, one hundred and seventy-four dead, and that number needs explaining, because almost none of them died in the gun battle. The warships off Casablanca came through it with light damage. Massachusetts, hit once, lost no one.

The Americans died afterward, in the transports. On November eleventh, the day of the ceasefire, the German submarine U one seventy-three got in among the anchorage off Fedala and torpedoed the transport Joseph Hewes, a destroyer and an oiler. About a hundred men died on Hewes. The next day, U one thirty sank three more transports, Tasker H. Bliss, Hugh L. Scott and Edward Rutledge, and seventy-four more Americans died. The French had failed to reach the transports with seven warships. Two German submarines reached them in two days.

Massachusetts sailed for home on November twelfth, the day after the ceasefire. She never fought another battleship. In nineteen forty-three she went to the Pacific and spent the rest of the war screening the fast carriers, from the Gilberts to Okinawa. She came through a typhoon in December nineteen forty-four that sank three American destroyers.

And in July and August nineteen forty-five, she stood off the Japanese home islands and bombarded the iron and steel works at Kamaishi, on the coast of Honshu. On August ninth, with the battleship Alabama alongside her, she shelled Kamaishi a second time. The Navy's official history says she fired, that day, what was probably the last sixteen-inch shell fired in combat in the Second World War. The first American sixteen-inch shell of the war and, probably, the last one, both came out of the same nine guns.

Jean Bart was repaired at Casablanca, sailed for sea trials in September nineteen forty-three, and spent the rest of the war as a training ship. France finished her at last in nineteen fifty-five, thirteen years after the duel, the last battleship any nation ever completed. She was scrapped in nineteen seventy.

Massachusetts was decommissioned at Norfolk on March twenty-seventh, nineteen forty-seven, and laid up in reserve. In nineteen sixty-two the Navy struck her from the list and ordered her sold for scrap. Her wartime crew, who had been holding reunions since nineteen forty-five, refused to let that happen. They raised money across the state, and schoolchildren in Massachusetts collected coins for her. In August nineteen sixty-five she was towed into Fall River, Massachusetts, where she still is.

A fragment of one of the sixteen-inch shells she fired into Jean Bart that morning is kept at the United States Naval Academy museum, a piece of steel dug out of a French battleship by French sailors in November nineteen forty-two.

Go back to four minutes past seven, November eighth. A six-month-old battleship, firing armor-piercing shells with twenty-year-old fuzes, at a half-built battleship that could not move, belonging to a country the United States was not at war with. Nine salvos. Sixteen minutes. Five hits. Then seven hundred and seventy more rounds across the rest of the day, at destroyers, batteries, a dry dock and an ammunition dump, until there were fourteen shells left in her magazines.

No American battleship ever fired on a French one before that morning, and none ever has since. Massachusetts did it on her first day in combat, and she did it with nearly everything she had.

More episodes on YouTube