The Submarine That Sank The Largest Aircraft Carrier In History
15 min read
The video for this episode is on the YouTube channel.
November twenty-eighth, nineteen forty-four. twenty forty-eight. The waters south of Honshu, Japan, near the island of Inamba. An American submarine cruising on the surface at night picks up a blip on her radar. The range is twenty-four thousand seven hundred yards. The blip is too large to be a destroyer, too fast to be a merchantman. The submarine is USS Archerfish, S S three eleven, a Balao-class fleet boat on her fifth war patrol. Her commanding officer is Commander Joseph F. Enright, and he is looking for redemption. What his radar operator has just found is not just a target. It is the largest aircraft carrier on the face of the earth.
Steaming away from the American submarine at twenty knots is the Japanese aircraft carrier Shinano. She displaces nearly seventy-two thousand tons fully loaded. She is eight hundred seventy-two feet long. She is heavily armored, built on the hull of a Yamato-class super dreadnought, and escorted by three modern destroyers. She was commissioned exactly nine days ago. She is on her maiden voyage, moving from Yokosuka to Kure to escape the reach of American heavy bombers. On paper, the engagement should never happen. Archerfish is a fifteen hundred ton boat rated at about twenty knots on her surface diesels. The target is moving at twenty knots.
A submarine cannot catch a ship that is as fast as it is. A submarine trailing from behind is mathematically out of the fight unless the target turns around. The Japanese task force has radar warning receivers and lookouts trained to spot a periscope feather in the dark. Shinano is protected by an armored belt up to fifteen point seven inches thick over her magazines, designed to shrug off heavy naval gunfire and torpedoes. Yet, within eight hours, Shinano will be on the bottom of the Pacific, taking more than fourteen hundred of her crew with her.
The path to that sinking began with a hull laid down in May nineteen forty at the Yokosuka Naval Arsenal. She was meant to be Warship Number one ten, the third battleship of the Yamato class. For a year and a half, Japanese shipwrights assembled the massive lower hull, installing the double bottom and the heavily armored magazines designed to feed eighteen point one inch guns. In December nineteen forty-one, construction was suspended. Then came the Battle of Midway in June nineteen forty-two. The Imperial Japanese Navy lost four fleet carriers in a single day. The strategic calculus of the Pacific war shifted instantly from the big gun to naval aviation.
In July nineteen forty-two, the Japanese Navy ordered a radical conversion. The great battleship hull would become an aircraft carrier, but not a standard strike carrier. She was to be a heavily armored support carrier. Her primary mission would be to carry reserve aircraft, fuel, and ordnance to replenish the frontline carrier fleets at sea. She would have a single hangar deck and carry only forty-two aircraft of her own, plus five spares, but she would have the capacity to transport dozens more. Her defense was meant to be impenetrable. Her flight deck was paved with three inches of steel armor, designed to withstand a eleven hundred pound bomb dropped by a dive bomber.
Below the waterline, she retained the Yamato-class anti-torpedo bulge and the thick armored belt over her vital spaces. The construction was one of the most closely guarded secrets in the empire. A tall fence was erected around the drydock. Workers were confined to the yard. Anyone speaking of the ship faced severe punishment. American naval intelligence knew Japan was building something at Yokosuka, but they had no idea of its true scale or purpose. Shinano was a ghost ship before she ever touched the water.
By the autumn of nineteen forty-four, the Japanese Empire was collapsing. The Battle of the Philippine Sea had gutted their naval air arm. Leyte Gulf had shattered the surface fleet. And American B twenty-nine Superfortresses were beginning their bombing campaign over the home islands. Yokosuka was no longer safe. The naval high command feared that a stray bomb could ignite the massive fuel bunkers or detonate the magazines of the unfinished carrier sitting in drydock. They ordered Shinano to be moved to the Kure Naval Arsenal, on the Inland Sea, where she could be completed in relative safety.
The order was a death sentence. Shinano was commissioned on November nineteenth, nineteen forty-four, but she was not finished. She was a floating construction site. She had never run her full-power trials, and she would sail at twenty knots instead of her designed twenty-seven. Most of her watertight doors had not been installed. Where they were installed, the seals had not been tested. The gaps around electrical cables passing through bulkheads had not been packed with fire-resistant compound. Her fire mains and bailing systems had no pumps installed. Her crew was equally unready.
Captain Toshio Abe, a seasoned destroyer commander, was given command of the behemoth. His crew consisted of raw conscripts, surviving sailors from sunken ships who had never trained together, and hundreds of civilian shipyard workers who were ordered aboard to continue building the ship while she sailed. Abe protested the move. He requested a delay to finish the watertight integrity tests and to train his damage control parties. The high command refused. On November twenty-eighth, Shinano slipped out of Yokosuka under the cover of darkness, escorted by the destroyers Isokaze, Yukikaze, and Hamakaze.
Waiting in the darkness outside Tokyo Bay was a captain who understood failure. Commander Joseph F. Enright had commanded the submarine USS Dace earlier in the war. In November nineteen forty-three, during his first patrol, Enright had maneuvered Dace into a firing position against the Japanese aircraft carrier Shokaku. But he hesitated. His approach was too cautious, daylight came, and he broke off without firing a shot. The failure haunted him. He asked to be relieved of command, believing he was not aggressive enough, and spent about six months ashore at the submarine base on Midway. But Admiral Charles Lockwood, commander of the Pacific submarine fleet, believed in second chances.
In September nineteen forty-four, Lockwood gave Enright command of USS Archerfish. Archerfish was a Balao-class submarine, laid down at the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard and commissioned in September nineteen forty-three. She displaced fifteen hundred twenty-six tons on the surface and two thousand three hundred ninety-one tons submerged. She carried ten twenty-one inch torpedo tubes, six forward and four aft, with a total of twenty-four torpedoes. By late nineteen forty-four, the American torpedo scandal was finally over. The defective Mark fourteen torpedoes had been fixed, their depth mechanisms corrected, and their magnetic exploders replaced or bypassed with reliable contact fuses. Archerfish was a tested weapon system. Her mission on this fifth patrol was to act as a lifeguard submarine for the B twenty-nine raids hitting Tokyo.
She was stationed off Honshu to rescue downed airmen. But on November twenty-eighth, there were no air raids. The bombers had been grounded by bad weather in the Marianas. Relieved of lifeguard duty, Enright was given permission to hunt. He moved Archerfish toward the mouth of Tokyo Bay, exactly where Shinano and her three escorts were steaming into the open ocean. Enright was about to get the second chance he had asked for.
At twenty forty-eight, the radar operator aboard Archerfish reported a massive contact at twelve miles. Enright came to the bridge. Through his binoculars, he could make out a dark shape on the horizon, massive and low to the water. Initially, he thought it was a tanker. But as the submarine closed the distance, the unmistakable profile of an aircraft carrier island emerged against the night sky. She was moving fast, making twenty knots, and zigzagging. The geometry of the chase was immediately against the Americans. Archerfish on the surface, running her diesels at maximum output, could make about twenty knots, no more than her target.
Shinano was making twenty. If the Japanese carrier simply steamed a straight line, she would walk away from the submarine. But Shinano was zigzagging to avoid torpedoes, altering course every few minutes. This base course allowed Archerfish to slowly cut the corners and maintain contact, but she could not gain enough ground to maneuver ahead of the target for a firing solution. The pursuit went on for hours. Archerfish stayed on the surface, her bow cutting through the swells, her engines vibrating the entire deck. The Japanese knew she was there. Shinano’s radar warning receivers had picked up Archerfish’s radar emissions.
Captain Abe was informed that an American submarine was trailing them. But Abe misinterpreted the situation. He believed that the American submarine was a decoy, placed there to force him to turn away and run straight into a waiting wolfpack of other submarines. His escorts, the veteran destroyers that had survived Midway and Leyte, detected Archerfish as well. At twenty-two forty-five, the destroyer Isokaze broke formation against orders and charged the submarine. Enright prepared to dive, but Abe recalled her. He would not let his screen be drawn away.
By midnight, the situation aboard Archerfish was growing desperate. Enright was pushing his diesels beyond their safe limits, but Shinano’s zigzag pattern was carrying her further away. The range opened. At oh one thirty, Enright realized he was losing the race. He did something submarine commanders rarely do when stalking a target: he broke radio silence. He transmitted a contact report to Pearl Harbor, giving the target's course and speed. He hoped that Lockwood could vector another submarine ahead of the carrier to make the kill. Archerfish continued to chase, but the target was slipping over the horizon. Then, the tactical picture inverted.
By oh two hundred, Captain Abe was convinced that the submarine trailing him was part of a larger trap. The Japanese carrier was approaching the Izu Islands. The navigational constraints of the islands forced a choice. Abe had to alter his base course to avoid the landmasses. Believing that a wolfpack waited to the west, he ordered a major course change to the south. At oh two fifty-six, she made the fatal turn. The massive carrier swung her bow around, pointing almost directly at USS Archerfish.
Enright could not believe his optics. The target that had been outrunning him for six hours had just turned around and presented her broadside. The closing speed was now immense. Archerfish did not have to chase anymore; she just had to slip beneath the surface and let the largest aircraft carrier in the world drive right across her torpedo tubes. The submarine that had been outranged and outrun by a twenty knot behemoth was suddenly in the perfect firing position. Enright ordered the boat to clear the bridge and dive.
At oh three oh four, USS Archerfish slid beneath the waves. The control room was silent except for the hum of the electric motors and the rhythmic pinging of the sonar. Enright took the periscope. Through the crosshairs, the colossal bulk of Shinano filled the lens. The sheer size of the target confused the submarine's fire control team. The rangekeeper, an electromechanical computer used to calculate torpedo trajectories, was fed the estimated length of the ship. Enright guessed she was a Hayataka-class carrier, but the ship in his periscope was vastly larger. The escorts were the immediate problem.
One destroyer was positioned on Shinano's starboard bow, bearing down on Archerfish’s position. Enright held his breath as the destroyer passed directly over the submarine, its propellers churning the water just feet above the periscope shears. The destroyer's sonar did not detect them. With the screen bypassed, Shinano's massive unarmored lower hull was exposed. Enright ordered the torpedoes in the forward tubes set to a depth of ten feet. He wanted to ensure they struck the hull just below the waterline, avoiding the deepest and thickest part of the Yamato-class armor belt. The range was closing fast.
two thousand yards. fifteen hundred yards. At oh three fifteen, Enright gave the order. "Fire one." The submarine shuddered as high-pressure air launched the first Mark fourteen torpedo from the tube. He fired a spread of six torpedoes from the bow tubes, spaced at eight-second intervals, fanning them out along the length of the massive target. The torpedo run would take less than a minute. In the control room, the crew counted down the seconds, waiting to see if the reformed torpedoes would actually explode, or if the nightmare of the early war would repeat itself.
At oh three seventeen, the first torpedo slammed into Shinano's starboard side toward the stern, flooding refrigerated storage and an empty aviation fuel tank. Over the next thirty seconds, three more torpedoes struck the carrier in a devastating sequence. The second hit the outboard engine room. The third struck near the number three boiler room, and the fourth flooded the starboard air compressor room and ruptured an oil tank. The explosions threw columns of water hundreds of feet into the air. Aboard Archerfish, the concussions rocked the submarine so violently that the crew thought they were being depth-charged.
Aboard Shinano, the initial reaction was misplaced confidence. Captain Abe felt the shudder of the impacts, but he commanded a ship built on a super-battleship hull. She was designed to take torpedoes and keep fighting. He ordered the ship to maintain maximum speed, believing the armored bulkheads would contain the flooding. He did not slow down to assess the damage. It was a fatal misjudgment. Pushing the damaged hull through the water at twenty knots forced thousands of tons of seawater into the open wounds at immense pressure. The unsealed cable penetrations and incomplete bulkheads gave way.
Water surged from compartment to compartment. The watertight doors that had not been installed allowed the ocean to rush unimpeded through the lower decks. The civilian shipyard workers, terrified and untrained, fled to the upper decks, abandoning their posts. The conscript crew did not know how to operate the manual valves. The few pumps that were operational were quickly overwhelmed. Within minutes, Shinano took on a ten degree list to starboard. The indestructible armor belt was useless because the water was bypassing it entirely from the inside.
By sunrise on November twenty-ninth, the situation was catastrophic. Shinano's list had increased to twenty degrees. The boiler rooms had flooded completely, killing the power. The great ship was dead in the water, a massive steel mountain slowly rolling over in the swells of the Pacific. Captain Abe ordered the port side voids flooded in a desperate attempt to counter-flood and right the ship, but it was not enough. The water continued to pour through the incomplete internal structure. At ten eighteen, with the list passing thirty degrees, Abe gave the order to abandon ship.
It was every man for himself. The crew began leaping into the cold, churning water. There were not enough life rafts, and many of the men were dragged down by the suction of the sinking vessel. Abe himself refused to leave the bridge, choosing to go down with his command. The Emperor's portrait had already been taken off to the destroyer Hamakaze. At ten fifty-seven, exactly seven hours and forty minutes after the torpedoes struck, Shinano capsized. She rolled over and slid stern-first into the depths. She took fourteen hundred thirty-five officers, sailors, and civilian workers with her.
The three escorting destroyers managed to pull one thousand eighty survivors from the water. She had been a commissioned warship of the Imperial Japanese Navy for exactly ten days. She remains, to this day, the largest warship ever sunk by a submarine. A seventy-two thousand ton leviathan, designed to be the ultimate armored sanctuary for the Japanese fleet, destroyed on her first voyage before she could launch a single aircraft in combat. The conversion that was meant to save the Yamato-class hull had instead doomed it to the bottom of the sea.
When USS Archerfish returned to Pearl Harbor in December nineteen forty-four, Commander Enright filed his patrol report. He claimed to have sunk a twenty-eight thousand ton Hayataka-class carrier. Naval Intelligence doubted the claim. They had broken the Japanese codes, they had aerial reconnaissance of every major port, and they insisted that there was no carrier of that size operating in those waters. They believed he had sunk a cruiser. Enright argued, drawing sketches of the massive island and the distinct sheer of the flight deck he had seen through the periscope, and he was credited with a twenty-eight thousand ton carrier. It was not until after the war, when American occupation forces found the blueprints and construction records in Tokyo, that the truth was confirmed.
Enright had not sunk a twenty-eight thousand ton carrier. He had sunk the ghost ship of Yokosuka. He was awarded the Navy Cross, the second highest decoration for valor. The destruction of Shinano was absolute, but the reasons for it were entirely practical. She was sunk because the Japanese high command prioritized the illusion of safety over the reality of watertight integrity. They forced an unfinished hull into the open ocean with a crew that did not know the ship and doors that did not close. And she was sunk because an American submarine commander, haunted by a missed opportunity a year earlier, refused to give up a six-hour chase when all the arithmetic said he should.
An armored behemoth designed to withstand the heaviest weapons afloat was torn open by four standard torpedoes, and drowned by her own forward momentum. She was the largest aircraft carrier ever built, and she was destroyed by a captain looking for redemption, commanding a submarine that simply waited in the dark for the enemy to make a mistake.