The 'Outclassed' American Cruiser That Crippled A Japanese Battleship At Point Blank Range
17 min read
At one forty-eight in the morning on Friday, November thirteenth, nineteen forty-two, two searchlights came on in the dark off Guadalcanal. In those few seconds, thirteen American warships found out they were not in front of a Japanese fleet. They were inside it.
One of them was the heavy cruiser USS San Francisco. Before her keel was laid, the Navy listed her, like every American treaty cruiser of the day, as a light cruiser, because their armor was so thin. Out in the darkness was the Japanese battleship Hiei, with eight fourteen-inch guns and a war that had begun at Pearl Harbor, where she escorted the carriers that made the attack.
Within minutes the two ships were twenty-two hundred yards apart, a little over a mile. Hiei's main guns could reach more than twenty miles. At twenty-two hundred yards, a battleship should not miss.
That night San Francisco took forty-five hits. Her admiral and her captain were killed. Every officer on her bridge was killed or wounded, and the one who took the conn had been knocked unconscious. She also put at least seventeen eight-inch shells into Hiei, and one detailed study of the battleship's damage suggests that San Francisco's guns made the hit that crippled her. By the next night, after a day of American air attacks, Hiei was on the bottom, the first battleship Japan lost in the Second World War.
This account is built from the Navy's own combat narrative, published in nineteen forty-four, and the Bureau of Ships damage report that numbers every one of San Francisco's forty-five hits. It also draws on Japanese records of what happened inside Hiei, and on the Medal of Honor citations of the men who brought the cruiser home. It starts eleven months earlier, on a morning when San Francisco could not fire her guns at all.
On December seventh, nineteen forty-one, San Francisco was in the Pearl Harbor Navy Yard waiting for a dry dock. Her engines were broken down for overhaul, the ammunition for her main and secondary guns was in storage, and her three-inch anti-aircraft guns had been taken off. When the Japanese planes came over, her crew had only small arms and two machine guns. A signalman, Ed Ifkin, remembered it this way: "Our guns were down, so a bunch of us climbed over to New Orleans." That was the cruiser berthed next to them, and they spent the attack passing ammunition to her gunners.
North of Oahu, two Japanese battleships were steaming with the six carriers that launched the strike. One was Kirishima. The other was her sister, Hiei.
Across the harbor, Commander Cassin Young was aboard the repair ship Vestal, moored alongside the battleship Arizona. When Arizona's forward magazine exploded, the blast threw him into the water. He swam back through burning oil, climbed aboard, moved his ship away from the fire and beached her before she could sink. He received the Medal of Honor for it.
Eleven months later, the cruiser that could not fire, the battleship that had guarded the attack and the officer who swam back to his ship would meet in the same stretch of water.
San Francisco was a treaty cruiser. The Washington Naval Treaty of nineteen twenty-two limited cruisers to ten thousand tons and eight-inch guns, and she was built to pack as much fight as possible inside that limit. She became a heavy cruiser because of the size of her guns, not the thickness of her sides. Her belt armor was five inches at its thickest. Her armor-piercing shell weighed two hundred sixty pounds.
Hiei was built for a different fight. She was completed in nineteen fourteen as a battlecruiser, to a design by a British naval architect. Disarmed under the treaties, she spent years as a training ship and as the Emperor's own ship, until Japan rebuilt her in the late nineteen thirties as a fast battleship, with an eight-inch armor belt and a top speed of thirty knots. Each of her fourteen-inch armor-piercing shells weighed fourteen hundred eighty-five pounds, as much as nearly six of San Francisco's.
The nineteen forty-four narrative summed up the matchup. At a conservative estimate, it said, the Japanese could throw three times as much metal per broadside as the American ships. The Japanese navy had also trained for exactly this kind of fight, at night and at close range, with better optics and far more powerful torpedoes.
On paper, a treaty cruiser at twenty-two hundred yards from a battleship lasts a few minutes. San Francisco lasted the night, and the reason was sitting in Hiei's magazines.
Since August nineteen forty-two, the waters off Guadalcanal had been fought over for one thing, an airfield. American Marines had taken it half-finished from the Japanese and named it Henderson Field. As long as aircraft flew from it, Japan could not bring slow transports to the island by day.
In the early hours of October fourteenth, Japan nearly put it out of action. Hiei's sisters Kongo and Haruna steamed in unopposed, and in eighty-three minutes they fired more than nine hundred shells from their fourteen-inch guns into the airfield and the ground around it. They destroyed forty-eight of the ninety aircraft there, burned almost all the aviation fuel and killed forty-one men.
In November, Japan meant to finish the job. Eleven transports were waiting with seven thousand troops. Ahead of them came Vice Admiral Hiroaki Abe with Hiei, Kirishima, a light cruiser and eleven destroyers. The battleships' magazines were loaded for the airfield, with Type three incendiary shells. According to a record of Hiei's movements built from Japanese sources, each one carried four hundred seventy incendiary submunitions.
Rear Admiral Richmond Turner sent his transports away and put all five of his cruisers, two heavy and three light, and eight destroyers in the Japanese path. The plan, in the words of the Navy's narrative, was to turn back the enemy's initial onslaught, cost what it might.
Command went to Rear Admiral Daniel Callaghan. He was born in San Francisco, he had been President Roosevelt's naval aide, and in nineteen forty-one he had commanded San Francisco herself. Now his flag flew in her again. He was slightly senior to Rear Admiral Norman Scott, who had won the Battle of Cape Esperance a month earlier with San Francisco as his flagship. Scott moved to the light cruiser Atlanta.
San Francisco had already been hurt. On the afternoon of November twelfth, a burning Japanese plane crashed into her after control station and killed twenty-four men. Her new captain had taken command on November ninth. His name was Cassin Young.
At midnight, now Friday the thirteenth, the thirteen ships entered Lengo Channel in a single line at eighteen knots. Four destroyers led, then Atlanta, San Francisco, Portland, Helena and Juneau, with four more destroyers astern. The moon had set. The narrative says simply that the night was very dark.
At one twenty-four the cruiser Helena's radar found the Japanese at twenty-seven thousand one hundred yards. Five American ships carried the new S G surface-search radar. San Francisco, the flagship, was not one of them. Callaghan was fighting from his bridge with his eyes and a crowded voice radio, and Helena's first report took six minutes to reach him. In those six minutes the two forces closed about four miles.
The Japanese were just as confused. A rain squall had scattered Abe's formation, and he was not expecting a ship-to-ship fight. At one forty-two his lookouts saw American ships about nine thousand meters away. Abe ordered his gunners to switch to shells meant for fighting ships. With incendiary rounds already lined up at the hoists, that took time.
The formations slid into each other. The destroyer at the head of the American line, Cushing, nearly rammed two Japanese destroyers, and San Francisco passed between two Japanese groups, two thousand and three thousand yards away.
At one forty-eight the destroyer Akatsuki and the battleship Hiei switched on their searchlights and lit up Atlanta. Callaghan gave his order: odd ships fire to starboard, even ships fire to port. No plan had ever numbered the ships, and the column no longer looked like a column. San Francisco, an even-numbered ship, opened fire to starboard instead. At least six American ships fired at Akatsuki, the brightest thing in the sound. She rolled over and sank within minutes, and only eighteen of her crew survived.
Atlanta took the reply. Shells from Hiei and the Japanese destroyers wrecked her, and a torpedo from the destroyer Ikazuchi cut her power. Out of control, she drifted across San Francisco's line of fire, and San Francisco fired into her. Atlanta later counted nineteen hits from eight-inch shells, and on her superstructure was green dye, the color of San Francisco's shells. When Atlanta's captain came back to the starboard side of his bridge, Admiral Scott and three of his staff were dead. The admiral who had won Cape Esperance with San Francisco as his flagship had been killed by her guns.
Callaghan ordered his ships to cease firing, most likely because he had been told Atlanta was under friendly fire. Not every ship heard the order, and not every ship obeyed it. Afterward, an officer on the destroyer Monssen called the whole fight a barroom brawl after the lights had been shot out.
Hiei, meanwhile, was coming straight through the American line, burning at the mast. The destroyer Laffey came out of a rain squall heading for the same patch of water. Laffey went to full speed and crossed the battleship's bow, and they missed each other by about twenty feet. That close, Hiei could not lower her guns far enough to hit her. Laffey fired her torpedoes, but they had no distance to arm, so she raked Hiei's bridge with every gun that would bear, down to her machine guns. Admiral Abe was wounded. His chief of staff, Masakane Suzuki, was killed. For the rest of the battle, the Japanese commander was limited in his ability to direct his ships.
San Francisco had already found Hiei. A few minutes into the fight, her guns trained on the battleship at twenty-two hundred yards. Two full salvos went out, and her officers saw hits at the waterline. Then came Callaghan's cease-fire, and she stopped shooting.
Robert Lundgren, who has studied Hiei's damage against the Japanese records, believes those two salvos were the ones that mattered. Japanese damage reports list a hole about one meter across, low on Hiei's starboard side, far aft, next to her after steering room. Her crew later tried to plug it with a rubber mat. Lundgren's verdict is that this may be the famous hit from San Francisco that eventually crippled her. Seawater was coming in beside the motors that turned Hiei's rudders.
When San Francisco opened fire again, close to two in the morning, Hiei was on her starboard bow with her searchlights burning. A Japanese cruiser was on San Francisco's starboard quarter, finding the range, and a destroyer was running down her port side with every gun firing. When Helena asked to open fire on targets of her own, Callaghan answered that he wanted the big ones, and he told the cruiser Portland to take the battleship along with San Francisco.
San Francisco gave Hiei everything she had. Hiei and the ships around her gave it back, and what the battleship gave back is why San Francisco survived.
The first shells out of Hiei's main guns were the ones loaded for the airfield. The narrative describes projectiles packed with small cylinders, some solid, some hollow and filled with incendiary material. With them came high-explosive rounds. None of those main-gun shells were made to pierce armor. Against an airfield, they burn aircraft and fuel. Against a warship, they wreck everything above the deck, the bridges, the gun directors, the radar and the men, but they do far less damage inside the hull than armor-piercing shells would. San Francisco was hit forty-five times that night, by battleship, cruiser and destroyer shells, and not one hit was below the waterline. The nineteen forty-four narrative put it plainly: what had saved her from complete destruction was the enemy's use of bombardment ammunition.
It did not save the men on her bridge. A battleship salvo struck the navigation bridge. Admiral Callaghan was killed. Captain Cassin Young, eleven months after he swam back to his ship at Pearl Harbor, was mortally wounded. The navigator and every other man on the navigating and signal bridges were killed or wounded. The nineteen forty-four narrative says the salvo came from Hiei, and Lundgren's later study of the damage agrees.
Steering and engine control moved to the after control station, the one the Japanese plane had set on fire the afternoon before. It was hit. Control moved to the conning tower. The conning tower was hit, and every way of signaling the other ships went dead. And as long as her main guns would bear, San Francisco kept firing at Hiei.
On that bridge, one officer came to. Lieutenant Commander Bruce McCandless, the thirty-one-year-old communications officer, had been wounded and knocked unconscious. Every other officer around him was dead or wounded. The flagship had no admiral, no captain and no way to signal the fleet, and she was in the middle of an enemy fleet.
Command now belonged to the senior surviving officer, Lieutenant Commander Herbert Schonland, the damage control officer. Schonland checked that the ship was being conned well, told McCandless to keep the conn, and went back below to keep her afloat and right side up. Water was pouring into the second deck through the shell holes. His citation describes him working in water waist deep, in darkness lit only by hand lanterns, until the water had been drained or pumped off.
In the hangar a fire was burning. Boatswain's Mate First Class Reinhardt Keppler, twenty-four years old, dragged a hose into it alone and brought it under control. Mortally wounded, he kept directing the fire parties and caring for the wounded until he collapsed from loss of blood.
McCandless tried to take the ship west, around Cape Esperance. A large ship opened fire on him, so he swung east, behind the Japanese. The other American ships did not know their admiral was dead. McCandless kept fighting her as the flagship, and his citation credits him with leading the column that followed her.
The American destroyers were being destroyed one by one. Barton took two torpedoes, broke in two and sank. Laffey was hit by shells from Hiei and then a torpedo, and blew up as her crew went over the side. Monssen was hit thirty-nine times in less than two minutes. Cushing burned until she sank. Portland took a torpedo in the stern and steamed in circles, and still put four salvos into Hiei, with ten or more hits.
Around two in the morning, Abe gave up. With his bridge wrecked, his flagship burning and his ships scattered, he called off the bombardment and turned away. By two twenty-six the shooting had stopped. The fight had lasted less than forty minutes.
Captain Gilbert Hoover of Helena, now the senior American officer still fighting, gathered what was left. When he found San Francisco, her lights had been shot away. By flashlight, the only means of communication she had left, she told him that Admiral Callaghan was dead.
When daylight came, Hiei was still there, northwest of Savo Island, steaming slowly in circles. The flooding aft had shorted out the motors to her rudders. Her crew had steered by hand until that compartment flooded too, and the rudder jammed hard to starboard. At dawn she fired on the crippled destroyer Aaron Ward, fourteen miles away. She could still shoot. She could not leave.
Hiei had come to destroy Henderson Field. Now the planes from Henderson Field came for her: Marine dive bombers and torpedo planes, Navy torpedo bombers from the carrier Enterprise, and Army B seventeen bombers. By one count built from Japanese sources, about seventy American sorties attacked her that day.
In the afternoon Abe, now aboard a destroyer, ordered Hiei abandoned. Her captain had her scuttled, and her crew carried off the portrait of the Emperor. That evening Admiral Yamamoto signaled that she was not to be scuttled. The order arrived too late. Hiei sank that night northwest of Savo Island, and one hundred eighty-eight of her crew went with her. She was the first battleship Japan lost in the Second World War. Yamamoto relieved Abe of command, and within months Abe was out of the navy.
Henderson Field was not shelled that night. Japanese cruisers shelled it the next night without putting it out of action, and in the morning its aircraft, joined by planes from Enterprise and Espiritu Santo, found the transports. They sank six and sent a seventh back to sink. Kirishima came back the following night and was sunk by the battleship Washington.
Admiral Turner wrote that this desperately fought action had few parallels in naval history, and he ended with this. These splendid ships and determined men won a great victory against heavy odds. Had this battle not been fought and won, our hold on Guadalcanal would have been gravely endangered.
The victory was paid for. The United States lost the light cruisers Atlanta and Juneau and four destroyers, and both American admirals in the battle were dead.
Worse came after the shooting. Later that morning San Francisco, Helena, Juneau and two destroyers were limping southeast toward Espiritu Santo. Juneau had been torpedoed in the night and was down by the bow, keeping station eight hundred yards off San Francisco. At eleven oh one the Japanese submarine I twenty-six fired torpedoes at San Francisco. They missed her. One hit Juneau, close to where she had been hit in the night. She broke in two and was gone in about twenty seconds.
Captain Hoover believed no one could have survived that explosion, and with crippled ships and a submarine nearby, he did not stop. More than a hundred of Juneau's crew had survived. A message asking for a search went astray. For eight days they drifted, wounded and thirsty, among sharks. Ten were rescued.
Among the dead were five brothers from Waterloo, Iowa: George, Frank, Joe, Matt and Al Sullivan. They had enlisted on the condition that they serve together. In January nineteen forty-three, three men in uniform came to their parents' door. Their father asked which one. The officer answered: all five.
Admiral Halsey removed Hoover from command, and later regretted it. Counting Juneau, that first night's battle cost fourteen hundred thirty-nine American lives.
On December eleventh, nineteen forty-two, San Francisco steamed under the Golden Gate Bridge into the city she was named for, the city where Daniel Callaghan was born, with the shell holes still in her bridge. Four Medals of Honor came out of that night aboard her, for Callaghan and Keppler after their deaths, and for McCandless and Schonland.
When the shipyard rebuilt her bridge, the old bridge wings came off unrepaired. Today they stand on a headland at Lands End in San Francisco, one of them still punched through by Japanese shells, set along the great circle course to Guadalcanal.
Bruce McCandless had a son. In July nineteen sixty-nine, Bruce McCandless the Second was the capsule communicator in Mission Control, the voice talking to Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin while they walked on the Moon. In February nineteen eighty-four he stepped out of the Space Shuttle Challenger wearing a jet backpack and flew away from the ship with no tether at all, the first person ever to do it.
Forty-one years before that, his father had come to on a wrecked bridge in the middle of an enemy fleet and taken the conn of a ship that should have been sunk. Hiei had come to Guadalcanal to burn an airfield. The cruiser the Navy once listed as a light cruiser went home. The battleship never did.