The 'Oldest' American Battleship At Pearl Harbor Was The Only One That Got Underway

17 min read

At eight forty on the morning of December seventh, nineteen forty-one, with Pearl Harbor on fire, one American battleship began to move.

She was USS Nevada, and by a few months she was the oldest battleship in the harbor. In commission since nineteen sixteen, she had gone to sea in the First World War. That morning she had a torpedo hole in her bow roughly forty-eight feet long. Her captain was ashore, and so was her executive officer. No tug came to ease her off her berth. The officer in command was a lieutenant commander of the Naval Reserve. The man at the wheel was a chief quartermaster, who had told the engine room to get ready before any officer reached the bridge.

Nevada was the only battleship to get underway during the attack. When the second wave of Japanese planes arrived and found a battleship moving down the channel, some of its dive bombers went for her. Half an hour after she got underway, the officers conning her did something that looks like a defeat in the photographs. They ran her aground on purpose, so that she would not go down in the only channel between the harbor and the sea.

This account is built from Nevada's own action report, signed by her captain eight days after the attack, and from the history written by Homer Wallin, the officer who ran the salvage of the fleet. It also uses the Medal of Honor citations of two of her men. It covers why she was the one battleship that could move, what happened to her in the channel, and why she was put ashore. Then it follows her past that morning, because at the end of that month Admiral Chester Nimitz looked at what was left of her and remarked that satisfactory salvage seemed impossible.

Nevada was laid down in nineteen twelve and commissioned in March of nineteen sixteen. When she was new she was a radical ship. She was the first American battleship with triple gun turrets and the first to burn oil instead of coal. Her main battery was ten fourteen-inch guns, and she could make twenty and a half knots.

She had been modernized once, between nineteen twenty-seven and nineteen thirty, with new boilers, tripod masts and anti-aircraft guns. The Naval History and Heritage Command calls her the eldest, by a few months, of the battleships in Pearl Harbor that day. Her sister Oklahoma went down the ways first, but Nevada was in commission first. The same history calls her an old, much-modified structure that proved to be, in its words, "anything but watertight." That matters later.

On the weekend of December sixth, the battleships of the Pacific Fleet at Pearl Harbor were all in port together for the first time since the Fourth of July. Seven of them lay along the shore of Ford Island, at the moorings called Battleship Row. Most were tied up in pairs, one ship against the quays and another outboard of her. Nevada was at the northern end of the row, directly astern of Arizona, and she was moored alone. The Navy's own history of the ship says this gave her a freedom of maneuver that the other battleships did not have.

The second piece of luck came from a twenty-one-year-old. Ensign Joseph Taussig Junior, the son of an admiral, had graduated from Annapolis ten months earlier, and he was the officer of the deck that morning. A battleship in port kept a single boiler lit for basic power. Taussig had ordered a second one lit, so that the load could be switched from one boiler to the other at about eight o'clock. When the attack came, Nevada had two boilers going and the other battleships had one.

Her captain, Francis Scanland, was ashore, and so was her executive officer. It was a peacetime Sunday. The senior officer aboard was Lieutenant Commander Francis Thomas of the Naval Reserve, the command duty officer, whose battle station was damage control.

At five minutes to eight the ship's band formed up on the fantail for morning colors. There were twenty-three musicians under their leader, Oden McMillan. At eight o'clock McMillan brought the band in on "The Star-Spangled Banner."

Walter Lord recorded what happened next in his book Day of Infamy. A Japanese torpedo plane that had just dropped on Arizona pulled out directly over Nevada's stern, and its rear gunner sprayed the fantail. He missed the band and the Marine guard, who were drawn up in two rows, and he shredded the flag that was going up. McMillan kept conducting. A second plane strafed, the deck splintered around him, and he paused, then picked up the beat again. The whole band stopped and started with him. Lord wrote that not a man broke formation until the final note died. Then everyone ran for cover.

Nevada's action report logs the attack as first observed at eight oh one. Her machine guns were firing at eight oh two. About a minute later her five-inch anti-aircraft guns opened up, each one firing on its own as its crew arrived, without waiting for the directors to be manned.

The torpedo planes came at her port side. One was hit by machine gun fire and crashed about a hundred yards off the port quarter, with its torpedo still aboard. Another got its torpedo away. It struck the port bow, abreast the forward turrets, about fourteen feet above the keel.

Wallin put the damage at roughly forty-eight feet long and twenty-five feet deep. The innermost torpedo bulkhead held, but its joints had opened and water came through. Nevada took a list of four to five degrees. Thomas was at the damage control station inside the ship, and the list was corrected by counterflooding. That worked, and it left her deeper in the water.

Then, directly ahead of her, Arizona blew up. A bomb reached the forward magazines a few minutes after eight, and one thousand one hundred seventy-seven of her men were killed. Burning oil spread on the water around the wreck. The captain's report says that Thomas judged it, in the report's words, "urgently necessary to get underway to avoid destruction of the ship due to the proximity of the Arizona, which was surrounded with burning oil and afire from stem to stern."

Nevada had been hit from above by then as well. Her report says one or two bombs had struck her before she moved.

One of the men wounded that morning was Taussig. He had gone up to an anti-aircraft director to control the guns, and he was hit there, in the thigh, and his leg was shattered. An account published in World War Two magazine has him looking down at it and remarking, "That's a hell of a place for a foot to be." He refused to be carried below. The action report says he went on directing the battery until his own director crew and the hospital corpsmen removed him. He had to be lowered to the boat deck in a stretcher, on lines, because fire had cut off every other way down.

Getting a battleship away from her berth was not a quick job. According to that same account, building steam in all the boilers usually took about two hours, and the move itself normally called for several tugs, a civilian harbor pilot, the navigator and the captain. Nevada had no tugs and no captain. What she had was two lit boilers and a chief quartermaster named Robert Sedberry.

Sedberry did not wait for an officer, and fleet doctrine was on his side. Under attack, the ships were to get underway. The action report commends his foresight, and it says what the foresight was: "ordering the engine room to prepare to get underway before the arrival of officers on the bridge." He then took the wheel and kept it. Lieutenant Lawrence Ruff acted as navigator, and Thomas came up from below and took charge.

The ship was still tied to the quays. Chief Boatswain Edwin Hill had been in the Navy since nineteen twelve. At the height of the strafing and bombing, he led his line handlers to the quays and cast off the mooring lines. That left him ashore with the ship coming free, so he swam back to her.

At eight forty Nevada backed clear of her berth with no tug to help her. The captain's report says that Thomas "got the ship underway within forty minutes." Then she went ahead, turned down the channel, and passed the length of Battleship Row.

She went by Arizona first, close enough that the heat was a danger to her own ammunition. Gordon Prange's history of the attack records that men on Nevada's deck shielded the shells with their bodies. After Arizona came West Virginia, sunk at her berth, and Oklahoma, capsized. Men ashore and on the other ships saw a battleship under way with her guns firing, and Lord recorded that they cheered.

At about the time Nevada got underway, the second wave of the Japanese attack reached the harbor. It had a hundred and seventy-one aircraft, and about eighty of them were dive bombers. They found a harbor under smoke and one battleship moving toward the entrance.

Pearl Harbor has a single channel to the sea. Prange wrote that the Japanese, seeing her, "recognized a golden double opportunity to sink a battleship and at the same time bottle up Pearl Harbor." Some of the dive bombers went for her. Counts vary with the source, from fourteen aircraft to twenty-one. They came at her from all points of the compass. Close by lay the seaplane tender Avocet, and her captain, Lieutenant William Jonson, wrote afterward that he had never seen "a more perfectly executed attack."

Nevada had little room to dodge. Ahead of her lay the dredge Turbine, with its pipeline run across to Ford Island, and the gap between the dredge and the Navy Yard's Ten-Ten Dock was narrow. Sedberry had to take her through it. Ruff lined up landmarks on Ford Island and fed positions to Thomas. The account in World War Two magazine speaks of "some real twisting and turning." Ruff remembered the bombs. In his words, "Their bombs jolted all hell out of the ship." His legs were black and blue afterward from being knocked around by the explosions.

As she passed the Navy Yard, five bombs hit her almost together. Wallin listed them. Two struck the forecastle near the bow. One of those passed out through the side, and the other exploded inside, near the gasoline tank, where the leaking fuel fed the fires. A third hit near number one turret and blew large holes in two decks. A fourth struck the port director platform on the foremast, went down through the bridge, and exploded at the base of the stack. The fifth burst over the crew's galley.

Her action report goes through the result deck by deck. The forecastle was split open and bent upward, and the navigation bridge burned out completely. On the boat deck, a bomb is understood to have set off anti-aircraft ammunition that had been laid out there. The report says the anti-aircraft gun crews were where the bomb hits caused most of the casualties.

Gasoline was now burning around number one turret, above the forward magazines, and it was an explosion in the forward magazines that had destroyed Arizona. Nevada's were flooded. So were her after magazines, by mistake, and that put her lower still. She also had a coincidence on her side. For several days the fourteen-inch battleships had been exchanging their shells for a new, heavier type. A vice admiral who wrote about it later in the Naval Institute's Proceedings recalled that Nevada's old shells and powder had been taken off and the new shells loaded, with the new powder due aboard that Sunday. The main magazines held no powder charges.

Her guns were firing through all of it. The action report claims three planes shot down just before the grounding, and says it is probable that at least five were destroyed near the ship during the morning. Those are one ship's claims, and the report itself notes that the accounts of her officers and men vary.

Nevada was now on fire forward and amidships, low in the water, and still short of the harbor entrance. And the fleet did not want her to go on.

Wallin records that while she was under way, a signal reached her that she should not leave the harbor. One account names Vice Admiral William Pye, the battle force commander, who had reports of enemy submarines. Rear Admiral William Furlong was watching from the deck of his own sinking flagship, the minelayer Oglala, and his fear was different. Prange has him thinking, "Well, there she is in the channel, and there is going to be trouble if that ship sinks in the channel." Furlong sent two tugs to help her.

The signal settled whether she would leave. By the account in World War Two magazine, what to do with a burning, flooding battleship in the middle of the channel was decided on her own bridge. Thomas and Ruff chose to ground her. They put her bow ashore at Hospital Point, on the Navy Yard side. Thomas's Navy Cross citation says that the entire forward part of the ship was on fire, and that it appeared she might sink under further bombing, so he ran her aground in order to save her. The time was about ten past nine. She had been under way for half an hour.

Those last minutes cost Nevada the man who had cast her loose. Hill had gone forward to the forecastle. His Medal of Honor citation says he was there, attempting to let go the anchors, when he was blown overboard and killed by the explosion of several bombs.

Below decks the fight was to keep the ship's power on. Machinist Donald Ross was in the forward dynamo room when smoke, steam and heat made it almost untenable. His citation says he forced his men to leave and did all of their duties himself until he was blinded and unconscious. He was rescued and revived. He went back and secured the forward dynamo room, moved to the after one, and passed out again from exhaustion. When he came to, he returned to his station and stayed until he was ordered to abandon it.

Captain Scanland got back to his ship by launch during the morning. By then her stern had begun to swing out into the channel that she had been grounded to keep clear. So she was moved again. Two tugs worked her bow free, and she went stern first across the channel to Waipio Point, where she grounded with her stern against the shore and her bow in deeper water. One of the tugs, the yard tug Hoga, tied up to her port bow and fought the forecastle fire for more than an hour. Avocet came alongside after noon and spent two hours on them.

The fires went out. The flooding did not stop. Water got into the main ventilation intakes and spread through the ventilation trunks, across a second deck that was not watertight. By Monday nearly the whole ship was flooded, machinery spaces included, and she had settled onto the bottom.

The Navy's Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships counts sixty of her crew killed and a hundred and nine wounded.

So what did the run achieve? It was not an escape. Nevada never reached the sea, and by the plain meaning of the word she ended up sunk. Wallin puts her in his chapter on the ships sunk at Pearl Harbor.

The idea that she saved the harbor from being bottled up needs care as well. That was the fear at the time, and the Japanese pilots seem to have shared the hope. But the channel was about twelve hundred feet wide. The historian Alan Zimm studied the attack in detail, and he concluded that a sunken battleship could not have blocked it, and that fourteen to eighteen dive bombers with two hundred fifty kilogram bombs could not have sunk her in any case. By that reckoning, the pilots who went after Nevada picked a poor target.

What the run did do is the thing her captain's report says it was for. It got her away from Arizona's burning oil. It was also seen, from the shore and from the other ships. One history of the ship calls her sortie "the only bright spot in an otherwise dismal and depressing morning."

Admiral Nimitz took command of the Pacific Fleet on December thirty-first, and he asked to be shown the wrecks. What Nimitz saw of Nevada, Wallin wrote, was a ship entirely filled with water, with her bridge burned out and her forecastle wrecked. Nimitz remarked that satisfactory salvage seemed impossible, and that they should not be over-optimistic.

Wallin thought otherwise. So did Nevada's engineering officer, Lieutenant Commander George Fee, who predicted that she would sail to the West Coast under her own power. Wallin admits that it sounded fantastic at the time.

The work went on into February. Divers fitted wooden patches over the bomb holes. A large patch for the torpedo hole, shaped against the upturned hull of her sister Oklahoma, would not seat, and after a month of diving it was given up. The inner bulkheads were shored instead. In all, Navy and civilian divers made more than four hundred dives on her, over fifteen hundred hours, much of it by feel and without lights.

It cost two more lives. On February seventh, Lieutenant James Clarkson opened a fitting in a cramped trunk and was killed by hydrogen sulfide gas from the stagnant water. A machinist's mate named DeVries, the first man to reach him, died later in the hospital.

Nevada floated on February twelfth, nineteen forty-two. Six days later the tugs brought her to the dry dock, and Nimitz stood at the head of the dock to see her come in. On April twenty-second she sailed for Puget Sound on her own engines, with both screws turning. Fee had been right.

She left the yard before the end of nineteen forty-two, rebuilt and rearmed. In May of nineteen forty-three she bombarded Attu in the Aleutians. In June of nineteen forty-four she was off Normandy. Nevada was the only battleship present at both Pearl Harbor and the Normandy landings. Off the French coast that month, German shore batteries straddled her twenty-seven times and never hit her.

There is one more thread back to that first morning. After the landings in southern France she went to New York to have her worn gun barrels relined, and the three guns that went into her number one turret had come from Arizona. They had been away being relined on December seventh. Nevada carried Arizona's guns to Iwo Jima and Okinawa.

After the war the Navy judged her too old to keep and sent her to Bikini as a target, where she survived two atomic bombs. On July thirty-first, nineteen forty-eight, sixty-five miles southwest of Pearl Harbor, the battleship Iowa and two other ships used her for gunnery practice. The shellfire did not sink her. It took an aerial torpedo to finish it.

Edwin Hill received the Medal of Honor after his death. Donald Ross got his sight back and returned to Nevada, and on April eighteenth, nineteen forty-two, Nimitz presented him with the Medal of Honor. He is recorded as the first man to receive it in the Second World War, and he was still aboard Nevada off Normandy. Francis Thomas received the Navy Cross. So did Joseph Taussig, who lost his left leg, stayed in the Navy, and retired in nineteen fifty-four as its youngest captain.

Ross died in nineteen ninety-two. His ashes were scattered at sea, over Nevada.

On December seventh the Pacific Fleet had newer battleships than Nevada in that harbor. The one that moved was the oldest of them, with a reservist in command, an ensign's spare boiler, and a chief at the wheel who did not wait to be told. She did not escape, and she did not save the harbor. She got under way and fought, and when she could go no farther, her own officers chose to put her ashore. Two and a half years later she was shelling the coast of France.

More episodes on YouTube