The 'Reluctant Dragon' American Carrier That Knocked Out Four Japanese Heavy Cruisers At Rabaul
17 min read
Late on November fourth, nineteen forty-three, at his advance headquarters on the island of Espiritu Santo, Admiral William Halsey was handed a plan. It would send the only two aircraft carriers he had against Rabaul, the main Japanese base in the South Pacific, in daylight.
Halsey wrote afterward that he expected the carriers' air groups to be cut to pieces. Of the carriers themselves he wrote, "I fully expected that they would be lost." His only son was serving aboard the bigger one. He read the plan and said, "Let 'er go."
That ship was U S S Saratoga. She was nearly sixteen years old, and no American carrier afloat was older. She had been torpedoed twice, she had missed Midway, and she had spent most of a year held in reserve. Her own sailors had names for her. One of them was the Reluctant Dragon.
The next morning Saratoga sent every plane she had into Rabaul. Seven Japanese heavy cruisers had been sent there to attack an American landing. When her planes left, four of them were out of action for months, and the Japanese never found the carrier that did it. No ship was sunk that day, and this account will not pretend one was.
It is built from the Army's official history of the campaign, which quotes Halsey in his own words, and from the Navy's history of the ship. The Japanese record of each cruiser is in it too, along with the aviators' accounts gathered by the historian Bruce Gamble. It starts with how a warship earns a name like the Reluctant Dragon.
Saratoga was never meant to be a carrier. She was laid down in nineteen twenty as a battlecruiser. The Washington Naval Treaty of nineteen twenty-two stopped that, and the Navy finished her, and her sister Lexington, as aircraft carriers instead. She was commissioned in November nineteen twenty-seven. She was eight hundred eighty-eight feet long, she could make better than thirty-three knots, and she carried a single enormous funnel, painted with a black vertical stripe so that pilots could tell her from her sister.
For fourteen years she taught the Navy how to use carriers. In a fleet exercise in nineteen thirty-eight she launched a surprise air attack on Pearl Harbor from a hundred miles off Oahu. The Navy's own history of the ship says it set a pattern the Japanese copied in December nineteen forty-one. One of her peacetime captains was a destroyer man named William Halsey, who had learned to fly at fifty-two so that he could take the job.
Then the war came, and it went badly for her. In December nineteen forty-one she was sent to relieve Wake Island and was recalled before she got there. On January eleventh, nineteen forty-two, a Japanese submarine put a torpedo into her southwest of Hawaii. Six men were killed and three of her boiler rooms flooded. She was in the yard at Bremerton while the carriers fought in the Coral Sea, and she reached Pearl Harbor on the day the Battle of Midway ended.
She fought in one carrier battle that year. Off Guadalcanal in August, at the Battle of the Eastern Solomons, her planes sank the Japanese carrier Ryujo. A week later a second submarine torpedo hit her. Nobody was killed, but the shock knocked out her electric drive, and for a time the eight hundred eighty-eight foot carrier lay dead in the water, under tow by a cruiser. She was still under repair at Pearl Harbor when the carriers fought at Santa Cruz.
She came back to the South Pacific in December nineteen forty-two and worked out of Noumea. The Navy's history says she spent the next twelve months providing air cover for minor operations. By the middle of nineteen forty-three she was the only American carrier in the South Pacific, and she was being saved, not used.
Sailors noticed. Bruce Gamble records three nicknames they gave her. One was Pond Lily. One was Sara Maru, Maru being the Japanese word for a civilian ship. The third was the Reluctant Dragon. None of them was meant kindly.
Her admiral felt it too. Rear Admiral Frederick Sherman, who took over her task force that year, wrote: "We on the carriers had begun to think we would never get any action."
Sherman had history with both the ship and the target. He had been Saratoga's executive officer in nineteen thirty-seven. He had commanded Lexington, and he was the last man off her when she sank in the Coral Sea. In February nineteen forty-two he had been Lexington's captain when she went toward Rabaul, for the first attempt at an American carrier strike on the base. Japanese planes found the task force four hundred miles out, and the raid was called off.
In the summer of nineteen forty-three Saratoga got new people and new aircraft. Captain John Cassady took command. A new air group came aboard under Commander Henry Caldwell, with Hellcat fighters in place of the old Wildcats. The fighter squadron belonged to Commander Joseph Clifton, a former Naval Academy football star known as Jumping Joe. In October the light carrier Princeton joined her. Princeton had been started as a cruiser and finished as a carrier, and she was eight months old.
On the first two days of November the two carriers finally got something to do. Their planes hit the Japanese airfields at Buka and Bonis, at the northern end of Bougainville. According to the Army's history, it was the first time an Allied carrier had been used in battle in the South Pacific since the Guadalcanal fighting, a year earlier. The reason for those strikes was a landing.
On November first, nineteen forty-three, about fourteen thousand Marines came ashore at Cape Torokina in Empress Augusta Bay, on the west coast of Bougainville. The point of the landing was an airfield. From Bougainville, American fighters and bombers could reach Rabaul, a little over two hundred miles to the northwest.
Rabaul was the base the whole Solomons campaign had been aimed at. It sat on the island of New Britain, around an anchorage called Simpson Harbor. It had five airfields and three hundred sixty-seven anti-aircraft guns. That week it also had the Japanese Navy's carrier pilots. Admiral Mineichi Koga, commander of the Combined Fleet, had just sent one hundred seventy-three carrier planes down from Truk to join about two hundred land-based planes already there.
The Japanese answered the landing at once. A cruiser force came down the first night, and Rear Admiral Aaron Merrill, with four light cruisers and eight destroyers, beat it in the Battle of Empress Augusta Bay. That force had two heavy cruisers. Then Merrill's ships, short of fuel and with exhausted crews, pulled back four hundred miles to refuel.
Koga did not give up. He ordered Vice Admiral Takeo Kurita south from Truk with seven heavy cruisers, a light cruiser and four destroyers. On November fourth an American patrol bomber saw them coming.
Halsey understood what it meant. The cruisers would refuel at Rabaul, run down to Torokina the next night, sink the transports and shell the Marines' positions. Another convoy was already on its way there with thirty-five hundred troops and five thousand tons of supplies.
He had almost nothing to stop them. His two battleships and a number of his cruisers had been sent to the Central Pacific for the invasion of Tarawa. Halsey called it "the most desperate emergency that confronted me in my entire term" as South Pacific commander. Even if Merrill had been fresh, he wrote, he would not have had a prayer against a force like that.
What he did have was Saratoga and Princeton, and they were five hundred miles from where they needed to be, refueling south of Guadalcanal. Some of his staff wanted to stand on the defensive. His operations officer, Captain Ray Thurber, did not. He worked out that if the carriers ran north all night at high speed, their planes could reach Rabaul while the cruisers were still taking on fuel.
Nobody had yet used carriers that way against a base like Rabaul. The Army's history says that up to then carriers had been used against land bases only in the most gingerly fashion. No carrier force had gone at a base this strong since the Japanese went at Pearl Harbor.
The staff carried the plan to Halsey. He asked if they meant to send Merrill to Rabaul. They answered, "No, sir. This is Ted Sherman again."
His chief of staff, Robert Carney, watched him read it. Halsey's only son, William Halsey the third, was Saratoga's aviation supply officer. Carney said every one of them knew what was going through the admiral's mind. His face, Carney said, "suddenly looked a hundred and fifty years old." Then Halsey handed the papers back and gave the order.
He explained it later in one line. He wrote, "We could not let the men at Torokina be wiped out while we stood by and wrung our hands."
The order reached Sherman just as his ships finished fueling. He turned northwest and worked the formation up to twenty-seven knots, and he held it there all night.
Aboard Saratoga, Captain Cassady called in Caldwell and the squadron commanders. He told them, "Boys, we are hitting Rabaul tomorrow morning. This is a hell of a tough assignment." If they failed, the enemy would very probably force the Americans to give up the landing. He told them to concentrate on the cruisers, and that Sherman had promised to have the carriers within reach when they were done. He said, "You have damn little time." Then he said, "God bless you, boys."
Sherman made one more decision, and it put every plane he had over the target. A carrier normally keeps some of her fighters overhead to protect herself. Sherman kept none. Halsey had ordered Navy fighters from the airfields on New Georgia and Vella Lavella to fly out and cover the two carriers, so every plane on both decks could go to Rabaul.
The pilots were given another instruction as well. Their main targets were the cruisers, and they were not to try to sink ships. They were to damage as many warships as they could. A cruiser too badly damaged to fight could not bombard the beachhead either.
On the morning of November fifth the task force was in the Solomon Sea, fifty-seven miles southwest of Torokina and about two hundred thirty miles from Rabaul. The weather helped. There was a steady breeze across the decks and there were rain squalls to hide in.
Saratoga launched thirty-three Hellcats, sixteen Avenger torpedo planes and twenty-two Dauntless dive bombers. Princeton added nineteen Hellcats and seven Avengers. That made ninety-seven aircraft. Every dive bomber in the strike was Saratoga's.
The flight took about two hours. Caldwell briefed his squadron commanders by radio on the way. They came up Saint George's Channel above thirteen thousand feet in clear air, and from fifty miles out they could see what was waiting in Simpson Harbor.
Six of Kurita's heavy cruisers were there: Atago, Takao, Maya, Suzuya, Mogami and Chikuma. The seventh was escorting troopships back to Truk. The six had only just arrived. Some were anchored. Some were alongside a tanker, taking on fuel.
Simpson Harbor had been called the Pearl Harbor of the South Pacific. The ship that had made a surprise air attack on Pearl Harbor, in an exercise in nineteen thirty-eight, was about to make a real one.
Caldwell swung the formation wide so that it would come in over the harbor from the north. That turn took seven minutes, and in those seven minutes the Japanese put about seventy fighters into the air, most of them Zeros flown by carrier pilots.
Lieutenant Marvin Harper was flying a Hellcat on the escort, tight in on the bombers. He remembered it this way: "We looked up with utter astonishment." With their numbers and their height, he thought, the Japanese should have cut the Americans apart.
They did not. The Japanese pilots were unfamiliar with the big blue Hellcats, and they held off. They tried to pull the escort away from the bombers, and Clifton would not let his men be pulled. His fighters stayed tight, and the Zeros stayed back. Then the guns opened up, from the shore batteries, from the ships, even from the main batteries of the cruisers, and the Japanese fighters had to keep clear of their own fire. Two Hellcats went down. The formation held.
Over the harbor the Dauntlesses came down to ten thousand feet, rolled over and dived.
In one of them the gunner called out the gunfire over the intercom. The bursts were behind them, he said. Then they were on the left, then on the right. A moment later he said, "I give up. They are all around us." A few seconds later a shell hit the plane squarely, and the intercom went quiet. The gunner was dead.
The Japanese record of each ship says what the bombs did.
Maya had just cast off her fuel lines. A bomb hit her aircraft deck above an engine room and started a fire that killed seventy men. She would be under repair and refit until April nineteen forty-four.
Takao took two bombs. One opened her hull below the waterline and damaged her steering. Twenty-three men were killed. She was not ready again until January.
Atago was fueling when three bombs landed right alongside. None hit her. The blasts flooded compartments along her side, and splinters swept her bridge. Twenty-two men were killed, and one of them was her captain. Her repairs ran to the end of December.
Mogami was hit between her two forward turrets and set on fire. Nineteen men died, and her crew flooded the forward magazines to save the ship. She left Rabaul with her top speed cut to twelve knots, and she was in the yard until February.
Chikuma took a near miss and slight damage. Suzuya was not touched.
The torpedo planes did less. By Japanese records two torpedoes struck home, one on a light cruiser and one on a destroyer, and neither exploded.
Getting out was the worst of it. The bombers went out across the harbor, weaving, sometimes hopping over a ship, through everything the fleet could fire. Lieutenant Commander Vincent Hathorn found himself looking into the eight-inch guns of a cruiser. All he could think to do was fire back with his two fixed fifty-caliber guns. He remembered thinking, "This is pretty silly, me dueling with this joker."
Above the harbor, Commander Caldwell had stayed behind to watch. He was flying an Avenger with a photographer aboard, Paul Barnett, and two Hellcats for escort. Eight Zeros came down on the three of them.
One Hellcat was knocked out of the fight. The other came home with nearly two hundred seventy holes in it. In the Avenger the gunner and the radioman fired until both were wounded. Barnett was photographing a Zero that was coming at them head on when a bullet struck him, and he died in the plane.
Caldwell thought he was the only man left alive in the plane until the radioman passed him a note. He flew back to the ship with no radio, no flaps and one wheel that would not come down, and he landed aboard Saratoga on the first try. A Navy photograph shows the deck crew lifting the wounded out of the Avenger while Caldwell climbs down from the cockpit.
When the planes were counted, the cost was nine or ten aircraft, depending on who did the counting, and about fifteen men. The Americans claimed twenty-eight Japanese planes shot down. Japanese records say four.
Halsey had expected to lose two carriers. Neither had been touched. Japanese planes went out looking for them that afternoon, and that evening they found two landing craft and a P T boat southwest of Torokina. They attacked those and reported a great victory.
Then the report reached Halsey. He wrote later that he took a deep breath, and so did the men at Torokina. His son was safe. His signal to the task force is where this story gets its ending. It read, "Report of attack is real music to me. When the Saratoga is given a chance, she is deadly. Princeton too takes a deep initial bow in the South Pacific."
On board Saratoga, Jumping Joe Clifton handed out cigars.
What had she done? The count that holds up comes from the Japanese side. Four heavy cruisers were out of action for roughly two to five months. A fifth was lightly damaged and a sixth untouched. Two light cruisers and two or three destroyers had minor damage. Nothing sank.
The American accounts do not agree with each other. The Army's history counts three heavy cruisers badly damaged. Gamble counts five of the six damaged in some degree. The repair dates in the Japanese records settle it at four.
It was not Saratoga alone, either. Princeton flew twenty-six of the ninety-seven planes. Navy fighters from the Solomons guarded both carriers all day, and Army bombers hit Rabaul's waterfront later the same day. But the bombs that stopped the cruisers came from twenty-two dive bombers, and all twenty-two flew from the Reluctant Dragon.
The Japanese reaction is the measure of it. On the following day Koga decided to pull his heavy cruisers back to Truk. In the words of the Army's history, after that no more heavy Japanese ships went to Rabaul. Kurita's cruisers were no longer a threat to Torokina.
The Marines kept their beachhead, and the airfields were built. Within weeks Rabaul was inside the range of land-based Navy and Marine bombers for the first time, and the South Pacific command's own campaign to grind the base down from the air began in the middle of December.
Six days later Saratoga and Princeton went back, this time with three new carriers, Essex, Bunker Hill and Independence. Bad weather spoiled Saratoga's part of that attack, and the new ships did most of the damage. The Japanese sent more than a hundred planes after the carriers and lost again. Of the one hundred seventy-three carrier planes Koga had sent to Rabaul, one hundred twenty-one were gone in under two weeks, and on November twelfth he took the rest home.
The losses reached past Rabaul. When the Americans landed in the Gilbert Islands later that month, Koga had planned to bring the Combined Fleet out and fight. The main fleet stayed at Truk. In the judgment of the Army's historian, the cruiser damage and the aircraft losses had completely immobilized it.
The cruisers were repaired and went back to the war. In October nineteen forty-four they sailed for Leyte Gulf, five of the six under Kurita, and in three days the American Navy finished every one of them as a fighting ship. American submarines sank Atago, his flagship, and Maya in the Palawan Passage. Kurita survived the sinking. The same attack crippled Takao so badly that she spent the rest of the war moored at Singapore as an anti-aircraft battery. Mogami was crippled in Surigao Strait and scuttled later that day. Chikuma and Suzuya were sunk in the battle off Samar. Within a year of that morning in Simpson Harbor, five of the six heavy cruisers were on the bottom, and the sixth would never sail again.
Princeton was lost in the same battle, to a single bomb.
Rabaul was never invaded. The Allies went around it and left its garrison, tens of thousands of men, to sit out the war.
Saratoga outlasted the war. She fought alongside the British in the Indian Ocean. At Iwo Jima, in February nineteen forty-five, she took five hits in three minutes and lost one hundred twenty-three men, and she still came home. After the surrender she carried twenty-nine thousand two hundred four veterans back from the Pacific, more than any other ship.
In nineteen forty-six the Navy anchored her at Bikini Atoll as a target for the atomic bomb. She survived the first one. The second, set off under water, finally put her on the bottom.
Her sailors had called her the Reluctant Dragon, because she had missed several of the big carrier battles and spent so much time in port. In November nineteen forty-three an admiral who had once commanded her gave her one morning, in what he called the most desperate emergency of his command, and expected never to see her again. Her dive bombers stopped a cruiser force, she came through without a scratch, and she went back six days later.
When the Saratoga is given a chance, Halsey signaled, she is deadly. On that morning over Simpson Harbor, she was.